It looks really good, on first inspection. There are some good additions to the rule-set, mainly inspired by other games. There is now an optional Trust mechanic (Cold City), for instance. Most abilities grant extra options once they hit 8+; these benefits are called Cherries (Unknown Armies). The chase and combat rules have been modified for gamers who want to ramp-up the octane in their games. There are some good options for vampires and plenty of room for a GM to concoct his own. The game can be run in several modes (much like ToC), from full-on spy action mayhem to low-key John Le Carre type shenanigans. The core conceit of the game is that the PCs stumble across a vast conspiracy, with vampires (or a vampire) at the top of the pyramid. The main geographical focus of the game is Europe, which makes for a pleasant change from the glut of US-dominated settings for modern RPGs.
It's an expensive one at £30. Pelgrane have done their usual high-end, glossy production, which always jacks up the RRP. In this case I believe the actual content is worth the expense. I believe that Kenneth Hite is a far better designer than Robin Laws and the gulf in quality between NBA and Ashen Stars is noticeably gaping. There is an adventure in the book, which is designed to be a springboard into a small campaign called The Zalozhniy Quartet. I haven't bought this, mainly because I already have the foundations of a conspiracy built, complete with notes and ideas about the cities I want to use; Budapest, Berlin, Venice and Barcelona. However, I think it would be good to play the included scenario as a taster.

Thanks for the kind words about NBA! I think you're being far too generous to say I'm a better designer than Robin: I think ASHEN STARS is terrific, and DRAMA SYSTEM and the new HEROQUEST are phenomenal. But both NBA and ASHEN STARS are very tuned to their genres, and if you like spy thrillers better than serial space adventure, you'll appreciate NBA maybe more than ASHEN STARS.
ReplyDeleteBut all that aside, I'm glad you're enjoying NBA, and I'm looking forward to reading your further reactions!
Firstly let me begin my response with, oh my word, Ken Hite left a comment on my blog! It's good to know that after 30 years of gaming I can still be elated to soaring heights.
ReplyDeleteMy post wasn't meant to denigrate Robin's achievements as a game designer; I regard the Dying Earth RPG as one of the finest games of all time. Rather, I prefer your approach to design and find a greater mental affinity for the stuff you do, especially the way you have adapted GUMSHOE for Cthulhu gaming and, now, for occult conspiracy spy thriller gaming. Furthermore, the fact that you wrote about Unknown Armies in 'Hobby Games - The 100 Best' merely cements you, in my mind at least, as person of impeccable taste.
I have run a few sessions of Ashen Stars and I am a fan of serial space adventure, in general. I wrote a post about my experiences running Ashen Stars, here:
http://nerdtropolis.blogspot.co.uk/2011/11/thoughts-on-ashen-stars.html
I'm truly sorry if my post read like a slating of Robin's work, that was not my intention. Whilst I'm not a fan of the bulk of his work I still respect him as one of the giants of RPG design.
{I just regard you as a bigger giant, a bit like Gonn Orta}
Oh yes, I forgot, I absolutely adore the ICON system and the LUG run of Star Trek RPG material. More applause and flowers for Mr. Hite, please.
ReplyDelete